Search Articles
Advanced Search
Gay News Sponsor
Gay News Sponsor
Gay News Sponsor
Gay News Sponsor
  About Us   WCMG Info   Publications   QueerCast   Blogs   Videos   Advertisers   Events/Lists   OUT! Guide
Windy City Times Current DownloadNightspots Current DownloadQueercast Current DownloadVideocast Current DownloadWindy City Media Group BlogsJoin Our Email List!Taste Dining and Food
Click here for only most current editions; click on red bars above for past editions.
  Windy City Times    Download PDF Issue
ENDA Battle Rages On
by Amy Wooten
2007-10-10

Although House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., temporarily halted any action on the Employment Non-Discrimination Act ( ENDA ) following the massive response of national and local LGBT organizations, the controversy over a version of the bill that excludes protections for trans people continues.

Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., after introducing a fully-inclusive ENDA, introduced an orientation-only version in hopes of an easier passage. He also introduced a separate bill that would cover gender identity.

In a statement released Oct. 3, Frank responded to criticism he received from Lambda Legal, explaining that he was merely seeking widespread support. He provided his reasoning for introducing a new version, stating, '…the one change that is made substantively from the old bill to the new one that I reintroduced is to drop gender identity. No words have been added or subtracted that make it easier to fire a gay man because of some effort to transform homophobia into dislike of effeminacy and I believe the law continues to be a strong bulwark against that.'

Beyond that, in the cases of employee benefits and religious exemption, the efforts we made to try to increase our scope ran into insuperable opposition and the changes I made in the bill that was reintroduced simply reflect changes that would have been made in the original bill in the Committee markup. I should note that in both cases, all of those involved in the drafting of the bill were aware that we were going to have to make those changes and I am not aware of anyone who raised any objection because the case for doing so was so overwhelming. What we have now is exactly what we introduced in past years that had widespread support.'

Recently, House Majority Whip James Clyburn released a statement defending Frank's decision. 'Despite the Leadership's strong desire to pass an inclusive measure, the whip count made clear that we simply lack the necessary votes to pass a gender-identity-inclusive version of the bill at this time,' he said.

Yet others don't want to compromise. Pelosi, at Human Rights Campaign's ( HRC ) recent national dinner, stated, 'I strongly believe that transgender individuals deserve the same rights and the same protections as an other Americans and will work to see that ENDA also protects their rights.'

Read more story below....

With action temporarily delayed by Pelosi, LGBT organizations continue to rally for a fully-inclusive bill, saying that massive lobbying efforts is the key. Many organizations and activists continue to also criticize HRC, the nation's largest LGBT organization, for what many have said is a weak stance, although the organization has since launched lobbying efforts of its own and a nationwide call to action at www.passendanow.org . On Oct. 4, a coalition of roughly 150 organizations announced United ENDA, a national campaign to win the passage of the original, fully-inclusive bill. HRC, as of press time, had not joined the United ENDA coalition, which now has about 255 signatories. The ENDA battle continued to make headlines on Oct. 3, when HRC's only openly transgender board member, Donna Rose, resigned because the national organization didn't voice opposition to the passage of a less-inclusive version of ENDA. In 2004, HRC's board voted to only accept a fully-inclusive ENDA. In a statement released by Rose, she said HRC's leader, Joe Solmonese, gave 'false promises.'

Rose felt the organization didn't play an active enough role. Over 90 other organizations immediately voiced opposition of the new measure and formed a national coalition while HRC stood silent.

'Organization after organization has seized the moral high ground knowing that this is a historic opportunity that cannot be squandered...,' Rose's statement read. 'There is a single significant organization glaringly missing from that list. The Human Rights Campaign has chosen not to be there.'

It wasn't until Oct. 5 that Solmonese, in a statement released to members, revealed the reasoning behind HRC's action.

'That final principle—staying in the game in order to influence the outcome—has thus far been almost unique to HRC,' the statement read. 'The actions we've taken based upon it have come under intense scrutiny by others. No matter now difficult it is to come under fire, however, we know that turning our backs on our relationships with Congress is not an acceptable strategy for HRC...

'…I won't leave anyone wondering about where HRC stands: we do not support the incomplete bill recently introduced in Congress and we only support a complete ENDA. Period.'

Despite concerns over HRC's strategy, multiple organizations have voiced their opinion that a fully-inclusive ENDA is possible, given enough support.

The legal community has also joined forces and lashed out against Frank's new bill, saying they won't back down, either. Transgender Law Center, along with the American Civil Liberties Union, Lambda Legal, the National Center for Lesbian Rights and Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, released a statement criticizing the splitting of the bill.

Kate Kendell, executive director of the National Center for Lesbian Rights called the revised ENDA 'a major step backwards,' as well as a betrayal of the trans community. In a statement, she also pointed out that sex stereotyping is also at the root of much work discrimination of lesbians and gays, so the bill hurts the entire community.

Share this article:                         del.icio.us digg facebook Email
Baldwin: Lesbian U.S. rep talks Obama, ENDA 2010-08-25
GOP suggests Kagan will promote gay agenda 2010-08-04
ENDA not on agenda 2010-07-21
WOMEN'S SOCCER Talking with the legendary Pia Sundhage 2010-06-09
PRIDE MONTH CALENDAR 2010-05-26
Gays: Time running out for ENDA 2010-05-19
Giannoulias announces LGBT agenda 2010-05-19
Pelosi promises votes on DADT, ENDA next year 2010-05-19
GetEQUAL disrupts ENDA hearing 2010-04-21
200+ groups push for ENDA 2010-04-21
Cleve Jones pushes Pelosi on ENDA 2010-03-24
ENDA sit-ins take place at Pelosi's offices 2010-03-17
Greg Harris' agenda: Marriage equality and more 2010-01-06
Madigan Testifies to Support ENDA 2009-11-11
U.S. Senate's first hearing on inclusive ENDA 2009-11-04
Media leaders unite to create Chicago LGBT calendar 2009-10-01
Media leaders unite to create Chicago LGBT calendar 2009-09-23
Media Leaders Unite to Create Chicago LGBT Calendar 2009-09-21
ENDA in Senate 2009-08-12
ENDA introduced in U.S. Senate 2009-08-05
Events Calendar 2009-07-22
Frank introduces trans-inclusive ENDA bill 2009-07-01
Frank introduces trans-inclusive ENDA 2009-06-24
Brendan O'Hara: America's Gay Bachelor (one of them, anyway) 2009-06-24
LGBT leaders focus on Obama's agenda 2008-12-17
Events on the calendar 2008-12-03
Obama's agenda and gay rights 2008-11-26
DANCE Men set this 'Agenda' 2008-09-03
008 MaseratiGranTurismo: Stendalissimo on wheels 2008-08-27
Pets: Calendar 2008-07-23
Chicago Pride Month Calendar 2008-05-21
Calendar Notes 2008-05-07
Calendar Notes 2008-02-27
See Windy City Times calendar 2008-02-06
Calendar Notes 2008-01-30
Year in Review: The Gay Agenda in Congress 2007-12-26
Congresswoman Melissa Bean on ENDA 2007-11-28
HRC-Chicago on ENDA 2007-11-28
No-Trans ENDA Passes 2007-11-14
SIDEBAR: Statements about ENDA's Passage 2007-11-14
Baldwin Statement on ENDA 2007-11-07
Trans-Less ENDA Passes House 2007-11-07
Views: Symbolism or Substance in ENDA Debate? 2007-11-07
ENDA Debate Tomorrow 2007-11-01
Calendar of events 2007-11-01
House ENDA Vote in Limbo 2007-10-31
Calendar: Kathleen Turner and Reeling Lesbian & Gay Int'l Film 2007-10-31
Gay-Only ENDA Passes Committee 2007-10-24
Illinois Gender Advocates Statement Oct. 19 2007-10-24
Trans-Less ENDA Passes House Committee 2007-10-17
ENDA: Gloves Come Off 2007-10-17
Local Gender Group Responds 2007-10-17
Cong. Tammy Baldwin on ENDA 2007-10-10
Representative Barney Frank speaks to House 2007-10-10
The Ins and Outs of ENDA 2007-10-10
Protest Targets LGBT Violence 2007-10-10
Letter from Donna Rose, HRC 2007-10-03
Letter to HRC from leaders 2007-10-03
Groups Back Trans-Inclusion 2007-10-03
Letter to HRC Continued 2007-10-03
ENDA Explodes 2007-10-03
ENDA Hearing, Holsinger's Troubles 2007-09-12
Dragons 2008 Calendar Available 2007-08-01
'Gay Agenda' Stalls in Congress 2007-07-25
Games Week Calendar, Wednesday 2007-07-12
Letters to the Editor: The ENDA Is Near, Your Health, Sporting Chance 2007-07-11
Human Rights Campaign gala, see calendar 2007-06-13
Calendar of events 2007-06-01
Pride Month 2007 Calendar 2007-05-23
ENDA Reintroduced in Congress 2007-05-02
Calendar item: Remembrance for Rene Van Hulle 2007-04-11
Musto at Sidetrack, see Calendar 2007-03-28
See the calendar 2007-03-21
March Identity Calendar 2007-03-01
42ND WARD CHALLENGER: BRENDAN REILLY 2007-02-21
Calendar 2007-01-01
Despair.com 2006-12-13
Identity Calendar 2006-12-08
A Baker's Dozen of Great Gift Recommendations By Women AND Children Books First Staff 2006-12-06
Dance performance calendar 2006-11-01
Prospects for the Gay Agenda in the Next Congress 2006-11-01
Identity Calendar 2006-11-01
Gay Games Attendance Exceeds Expectations 2006-08-09
Games Week Calendar, Sunday, July 23 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Friday, July 21 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Saturday, July 22 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Thursday, July 20 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Tuesday, July 18 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Monday, July 17 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Sunday, July 16 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Saturday, July 15 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Friday, July 14 2006-07-12
Games Week Calendar, Wednesday, July 12, and Thursday, July 13 2006-07-12
DC Cowboys Bare All for Calendar 2006-06-28
Rugby Stars Shine for Benefit Calendar 2005-12-07
Gay rugby players produce sexy calendar 2005-09-14
Identity Calendar 2005-09-01
IDENTITY CALENDAR 2005-07-01
International Mr. Leather calendar of events 2005-05-25
Lutheran Panel Issues Recommendations 2005-01-19
Images Calendar 2004-11-01
ENDA as We've Known It Must Die 2004-08-11
HRC Moves to Add Trans to ENDA 2004-08-11
Blacklines Calendar 2003-12-01
En La Vida CALENDAR 2003-12-01
LEGENDARY FLAMENCO GUITARIST ESTEBAN TO APPEAR AT PABST THEATER 2003-09-01
All Together Now: ENDA to Include Gender Identity 2003-06-25
Feature: Is There A Gay Agenda? 2003-06-25
VIEWS: THE TRANSGENDER COMMUNITY & ENDA 2003-06-18
GLSEN and NCLR: Title IX Recommendations Threaten Opportunities and Safety of Girls and Women in All Schools 2003-03-05
Legendary Tillery at Old Town School 2003-01-29
Smallpox Vaccine Could Endanger HIV, Cancer Patients 2002-10-09
Local Calendar 2002-09-25
Movie Maven's video recommendations 2001-12-12
Movie Maven's video recommendations 2001-12-05
MUSIC FALL CALENDAR 2001-09-26
REDEFINING THE GAY AGENDA 2001-08-08
ENDA BACK IN MIX 2001-08-08






Gay News Sponsor
 
Gay News Sponsor
 
Gay News Sponsor
 
Gay News Sponsor
 
Gay News Sponsor
 
 
 

Copyright © 2010 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. Back issues available for $3 per issue (postage included).
Return postage must accompany all manuscripts,
drawings, and photographs submitted if they are to be returned,
and no responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.
All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and
Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication)
will be treated as unconditionally assigned for publication
purposes and as such, subject to editing and comment.
The opinions expressed by the columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators
are their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and
Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication)
does not indicate the sexual orientation of such individuals or groups.
While we encourage readers to support the advertisers who make this newspaper possible,
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and
Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication)
cannot accept responsibility for advertising claims.

Windy City Media Group produces Windy City Queercast, and publishes Windy City Times,
The Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community,
Nightspots, Out! Resource Guide, and Identity.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 ♦ PH (773) 871-7610 ♦ FAX (773) 871-7609.
www.windycitymediagroup.com
contact editor  ♦  contact advertising  ♦  contact webmaster

Website Powered by Materville Studios / LoveYourWebsite.com

 

Mayor Daley not seeking re-election
 
Blossom Boys: Business blooms on the South Side
 
Runway's Tim Gunn makes it work
 
LGBT veterans honored by City of Chicago
 
TRAVEL Cleveland rocks!
 



Gay News Sponsor



    

    

    


cheerful-nonunion